
As
price action traders, we primarily study charts and price bars, and the
price bars in each time frame show us the ‘emotion’ of price for that
specific period of time. Whether it’s a 1 hour, 4 hour or daily chart,
each price bar on the chart shows the ‘emotion’ and sentiment for the
period of time it reflects. For example, on a 1 hour chart we will be
able to see the emotion and feeling of the market over the last hour by
looking at the last price bar on that chart. That said, a 1 hour chart
or a 4 hour chart is going to show us a lot more data, emotion and
insight into the market than a 5 minute chart will, would you agree?
Would you also agree that the daily chart will show us even more emotion
than a 1 hour chart or 4 hour chart?
Today, I’m not just going to tell you what time frame to trade, but I’m going to explain to you why
time frames influence the signal you’re trading, stop placement on a
trade and the chances of winning and losing a trade. The implications of
these points are profound, yet they are often over-looked or ignored by
day-traders and scalpers. I am going to show you some evidence of why
you need to take this stuff seriously and turn off your low time frame
charts once and for all.
The connection between time and trustworthiness of a relationship
Think of the market like a personal relationship between two people;
the longer you’ve known someone, the more you know whether or not you
can trust them, right? If someone shows you they are a trustworthy
person over time then you will probably trust them, however, if a person
lies a lot you may actually trust them less as you get to know them…but
the point is that until
you’ve spent time getting to know a person, you really can’t make any
judgments about them, one way or the other.
To give you a more specific example; when you meet someone for the
first time, can you really get a good feel for their personality and
character in just 5 minutes of talking to them? Or would it take a full
day of conversation to get a more accurate feel for their personality
and overall mood? The longer you’ve known someone, the better “feel” you
have for who they really are.
It’s really very similar in trading; the more you study
higher time frame charts
like the 4 hour and daily, the better ‘feel’ you develop for the market
because you are getting to know more about it and you can see the
“bigger picture” a lot easier than you can on smaller time frames. The
higher time frames carry more weight because they display more data and
show more time than a smaller time frame does. If you are just studying 5
minute or 15 minute charts all the time, you are missing out on the
bigger, more significant picture of the market. You’ve probably
witnessed this with a long-time friend; you can almost figure out how
they will react in any situation…whereas with a complete stranger whom
you’ve known for only 5 or 10 minutes, this would almost be impossible;
it’s obviously because you’ve had more time to study and learn about
your friend.
Let’s look at a chart example of how a 5 minute chart really does not
tell you much about the “bigger picture” of a market. Below, we see the
5 minute USDJPY chart, and from this data we really cannot tell if the
overall trend is up or down, as the market appears to just be ebbing and
flowing very quickly and without much underlying or consistent
sentiment:

Next, let’s compare that 5 minute chart above to a daily chart time
frame of the same market; USDJPY. From the chart below, even a 6 year
old can tell that overall price is moving up; there’s an uptrend
underway. Due to the simple fact that you are getting to know more about
the market from looking at more data, you are learning some very very
important things about it (that the trend is up!) that you cannot tell
from just looking at the 5 minute chart.

Another example; if you are traveling and you stay in a town you’ve
never been in before for one week, and it rained the whole week, would
you tell everyone it “rains a lot in that town”? Or would you agree that
you really need to stay in that town for longer and observe its
longer-term weather patterns to make such a judgment? Most of us would
agree that you need more than one week’s data to judge a town’s overall
weather pattern…in other words, a week inside of a year is basically
just noise. You can’t make an assumption about a town’s weather pattern
unless you look over a longer period of time. Similarly, it’s nearly
impossible to read a market’s underlying sentiment without analyzing
higher time frame charts.
Longer time periods = more data = more evidence / proof.
Why lower time frames are “noise”
Simply comparing a 5 minute chart to a 1 hour chart will show you how
many more failed signals there are on lower time frames. The underlying
reason as to why lower time frames (I consider anything under a 1 hour
chart to be a “low time frame”) have more failed signals than their
higher time frame counter parts, is because there will be a lot more
meaningless price movement on a 5 minute chart than on a 1 hour. For
example, if you were to just look at one price bar on a 1 hour chart,
you would not see all the 5 minute incremental movements that made up
that 1 hour period….you would instead see the collective picture of all
those 5 minute movements.
You simply are not going to get a very strong directional movement
out of a 5 minute or 15 minute chart signal, instead, you will get a lot
of little meaningless movements. You’ll get a much stronger directional
movement out of a 1 hour signal and even more out of a 4 hour signal
and yet more out of a daily chart signal. You can expect more movement
from a signal the higher up in time frame you go.
In the chart below, we are looking at some recent price action on the
5 minute EURUSD chart. You can see that there were a lot more
pin bar signals
that probably would have been losing trades than there were winning
trades. This demonstrates clearly the fact that whilst there are more
signals on lower time frames…more signals does not equal more money, in
fact it usually means more losing trades and lost money.

Next, let’s look at the price action that occurred on the 1 hour
EURUSD chart around the same time as the 5 minute image above. The first
thing you should immediately notice is that there were a lot less
losing trades and a lot more winning trades. It’s because there were
less false-signals on the 1 hour chart since the 1 hour chart filters
out a lot of that “noise” on the 5 minute chart.
Market noise and daily ranges
Markets move in statistical average ranges each day; meaning there’s a
certain average range that the market is probably going to move within
on any given day. These average ranges will change over time as markets
become more or less volatile, but you need to be aware how they affect
your trades. The thing about these average ranges that many
day traders and scalpers
are seemingly unaware of, is that if you’re trading a small time frame
and you place a stop loss on that small time frame, the chances that you
will get stopped out simply because your stop is within the average
statistical range of the higher time frame, are quite high.
If you’re trading a higher time frame, your stop loss is likely to be
outside of the average daily range of the market so you are unlikely to
get stopped out from the random intra-day market noise that occurs each
day. Now, that’s not to say I want you guys to place wider stops, I’m
telling you to be aware that
stop loss placement
is a big factor in your success or failure as a trader and you need to
be aware how time frames affect stop loss placement. It’s pretty obvious
that if your stop loss is close to the current market price, as it is
on lower-time frame trades, it’s more likely to get hit than if you’re
trading the higher time frames.
Small time frames demand a lot of attention.

Would
you like to check the market every 5 minutes or every 4 hours? The
higher the time frame, the less you have to check the markets. If you
are like most people, you probably have a full-time job or full-time
school, or maybe even both; most people simply don’t have the time to
sit at their computers all day trying to trade a 5 minute chart. It’s
also a lot more stressful, so it really just makes no sense to try and
‘force’ money out of the market by scalping or day-trading.
I am a huge proponent of ‘letting the trades come to me’. Meaning, I
check the markets two or three times a day and look for obvious signals,
primarily on the daily and 4 hour charts, and if nothing meets my
criteria for a trade setup, I don’t trade…I go do something else
instead. I don’t sit there ruminating over the market all day wishing
and hoping for a trade like many beginning and struggling traders do. I
really do not care if I am in the market or not on any given day, and
this is the attitude and
trading mindset
that you need if you want to trade completely devoid of emotional
attachment to the market. My point is simply this; focusing on higher
time frames is much better for busy professionals as well as for people
who don’t want to have the stress of being glued to their charts all
day. It also allows you to employ my
crocodile trading method which is a cornerstone of my overall trading theory and strategy.
Small time frames elicit over-trading
“Over-trading”, also known as trading when no obvious signal is
present, or taking “stupid” trades, or “gambling”, is something I have
discussed quite a bit in other articles, so I won’t get into it too much
today. However, I will say that trading low time frames like the 5
minute and 15 minute charts, etc. is one of the biggest reasons
why traders trade too frequently.
The longer you park your ‘bottom’ in your computer chair watching the 5
minute chart tick up and down, the greater the chance you will
rationalize a reason to be in the market.
If you sit there staring at a 5 minute chart all day, the odds of you
actually not entering a trade are extremely low. As humans, we struggle
with self-control and self-discipline, especially when we put ourselves
directly in the realm of temptation, like when trading low time frames.
However, one area that we are lucky in as humans, is that we can plan
ahead and avoid temptation altogether if we put our minds to it.
Just
as not buying junk food at the supermarket is the easiest way to avoid
eating it…not immersing yourself in low time frame charts is the best
way to avoid the temptation to constantly be in the market.
Learn, change, grow…

I
obviously cannot speak for everyone in the trading world, but the
traders who contact me on a regular basis about struggling in the market
and blowing out their accounts, are typically the ones who trade the
lower time frames…that has to say something right? From these
experiences that I’ve had with other traders over the years, it’s pretty
safe to say that ‘social evidence’ suggests that a main cause of
failure in the market is trading low time frame charts. However, don’t
take my word for it, last year we had over 15,000 emails hit our inbox,
and I can comfortably say that the majority of the struggling traders
I’ve helped were trying to trade small time frames.
Thus, YOU should do something different…don’t be like the masses of
failing traders who are constantly searching for trades on the low time
frame charts. Have patience, trade only the higher time frames (1hr,
4hr, daily time frames are my favorites) and see if your trading doesn’t
just slowly but steadily improve.
If you want to learn more about higher time frame trading and how it
can improve your trading results by filtering out meaningless market
‘noise’ and allowing you to see the ‘bigger picture’ of the market,
checkout my
Price action trading course.
thanks for those insightful thoughts. I am enriched by them. More wisdom to you.
Thank you nial for teaching us patience and preserverance.
May your days be long on this earth.
Thanks Nial
Paul G
+
Price Action Pattern
is the best trading approach, I discover after about 12 years of trading.
I learned from Al brooks, Neil and Galen woods. Thanks guru’s.
Thanks Neil for this post, very very useful…
made more,better and consistent progress than ever.
ALL THANKS TO Mr NIAL FULLER.